People's Justice

Injury guide

A stuck shoulder during birth: care and claim questions

Shoulder dystocia means a baby’s shoulder gets stuck after the head is born. It is a birth emergency.

See If You Qualify

Free · No obligation · About 2 minutes

Updated Oct 4, 202618 sources

This may apply to you if

  • Prepare the birth, care and diagnosis dates you know; mark uncertain details.
  • Ask for a review of the care standard, possible harm and evidence linking the two.
  • Ask a lawyer to check the actual claim, legal authority and filing requirements.

What the public record says

These are cited sources. Their inclusion does not imply that they endorse People’s Justice or reviewed this page.

The evidence and its limits

Bordeaux University Hospital · Scientific Reports · 2023

Shoulder dystocia prediction after attempted operative delivery

Design:
Cohort
Participants:
2118 term attempted operative vaginal deliveries;57 shoulder dystocia events
Finding:
The prediction model failed to accurately predict shoulder dystocia in that setting.
Main limitation
Original abstract/metadata, not full paper. Restricted delivery group, limited events and observational prediction model; no universal prevention or standard-of-care rule.

Read the source: Shoulder dystocia prediction after attempted operative delivery (opens in a new tab) · Checked Oct 4, 2026

American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons

AAOS educational guidance on arm nerve injury after birth

Design:
Other study design
Participants:
Educational care guidance; no newly enrolled study participants
Finding:
Arm nerve injury needs clinical assessment and an individual follow-up plan, which can include therapy and sometimes surgery.
Main limitation
Care guidance, not a newly recruited study or agency trial review. No exact publication date found; no personal recovery forecast, exercise instruction or legal-fault determination.

Read the source: AAOS educational guidance on arm nerve injury after birth (opens in a new tab) · Checked Oct 4, 2026

Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists · 2013

RCOG patient guidance on shoulder dystocia and infant nerve injury

Design:
Other study design
Participants:
UK patient-care guidance; no newly enrolled trial population
Finding:
A stuck shoulder is a delivery emergency; arm nerve injury can occur without that event and after C-section.
Main limitation
Published March2013 with no exact day. UK educational guidance, not the current standard in every US setting, an original trial or a finding about one birth.

Read the source: RCOG patient guidance on shoulder dystocia and infant nerve injury (opens in a new tab) · Checked Oct 4, 2026

The short answer

What is shoulder dystocia?
The head has been born, but a shoulder is stuck. The delivery team must respond to this emergency. This page is not a guide to perform birth maneuvers. [16]
What signs or harm may follow?
The baby may have an arm nerve injury or a fracture. Some babies have no lasting injury. Ask the team what the post-birth exam showed. [16]
What should I ask about diagnosis and care?
Ask which injury was found and what follow-up is needed. Arm weakness needs assessment. The care plan should depend on your baby’s condition. [17]
What does the shoulder prediction study show?
The study’s risk model did not predict this event well. It covered assisted vaginal births at term. It does not prove your event could be prevented. [18]

The process

What happens next

  1. 01

    You answer a few questions

    About two minutes. Nothing is sent until you agree on the last step and press submit.

  2. 02

    A lawyer looks at it

    A lawyer at the firm reads your answers and checks them against the current case criteria.

  3. 03

    The firm decides and gets in touch

    If the firm takes your case, you get the terms in writing to read before you sign. You can always say no.

When it fits this case

  • Prepare the birth, care and diagnosis dates you know; mark uncertain details.
  • Ask for a review of the care standard, possible harm and evidence linking the two.
  • Ask a lawyer to check the actual claim, legal authority and filing requirements.

Shoulder dystocia means a baby’s shoulder gets stuck after the head is born. It is a birth emergency. A claim review must check the response and harm, not assume fault.

What is shoulder dystocia?

The head has been born, but a shoulder is stuck. The delivery team must respond to this emergency. This page is not a guide to perform birth maneuvers.

RCOG’s UK patient guide describes the event and the help needed. Its general explanation is not a current rule for how every US birth team should act or a judgment about your delivery.

What signs or harm may follow?

The baby may have an arm nerve injury or a fracture. Some babies have no lasting injury. Ask the team what the post-birth exam showed.

RCOG explains that nerve injury can also occur without a stuck shoulder. A diagnosis after birth therefore does not identify the delivery event or prove a breach of care by itself.

What should I ask about diagnosis and care?

Ask which injury was found and what follow-up is needed. Arm weakness needs assessment. The care plan should depend on your baby’s condition.

AAOS describes repeat examination and therapy for arm nerve injury, with surgery in some cases. Those options are not instructions for every child after a difficult delivery. Ask your treating team for the actual plan.

What does the shoulder prediction study show?

The study’s risk model did not predict this event well. It covered assisted vaginal births at term. It does not prove your event could be prevented.

Researchers studied 2,118 such deliveries, including 57 events. A narrow prediction cohort does not test every birth or the quality of an emergency response. Its finding must stay within that setting.

Does a stuck shoulder qualify us for a claim?

The event alone does not decide that. A lawyer must examine what care was required, what happened and whether a failure caused harm.

California’s court guide illustrates those separate proof questions. A difficult delivery and a bad outcome are not substitutes for the actual record and applicable law. Ask for a personal assessment.

Which birth and care records help?

Keep the birth report and baby’s exam records. Ask the provider about covered copies and who can request them. Note any missing pages or unclear dates.

The child’s record and the delivering parent’s record concern different patients. Confirm your authority for each request rather than assume one relationship grants access to every file.

Find out where you stand.

The review is free and private. Asking for it doesn’t commit you to anything.

Register your interest

Sources

  1. CDC: cerebral palsy risk factorsCDC: cerebral palsy risk factors · regulator
  2. ACOG and AAP: The Apgar ScoreACOG and AAP: The Apgar Score
  3. Zanelli et al.: Therapeutic Hypothermia for Neonatal Hypoxic-Ischemic Encephalopathy: Clinical ReportZanelli et al.: Therapeutic Hypothermia for Neonatal Hypoxic-Ischemic Encephalopathy: Clinical Report · study
  4. Shankaran et al.: Whole-body hypothermia for neonates with hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathyShankaran et al.: Whole-body hypothermia for neonates with hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy · study
  5. Faix et al.: Whole-Body Hypothermia for Neonatal Encephalopathy in Preterm Infants 33 to 35 Weeks’ Gestation: A Randomized Clinical TrialFaix et al.: Whole-Body Hypothermia for Neonatal Encephalopathy in Preterm Infants 33 to 35 Weeks’ Gestation: A Randomized Clinical Trial · study
  6. Laptook et al.: Effect of Therapeutic Hypothermia Initiated After 6 Hours of Age on Death or Disability Among Newborns With Hypoxic-Ischemic Encephalopathy: A Randomized Clinical TrialLaptook et al.: Effect of Therapeutic Hypothermia Initiated After 6 Hours of Age on Death or Disability Among Newborns With Hypoxic-Ischemic Encephalopathy: A Randomized Clinical Trial · study
  7. California Courts: rules when suing a healthcare providerCalifornia Courts: rules when suing a healthcare provider · court
  8. ABA Model Rule 1.5: feesABA Model Rule 1.5: fees
  9. Southern District of New York: filing time limitsSouthern District of New York: filing time limits · court
  10. HHS: Your Medical RecordsHHS: Your Medical Records · regulator
  11. NICHD: Neonatal Research NetworkNICHD: Neonatal Research Network · regulator
  12. 45 CFR164.502(g): personal representatives45 CFR164.502(g): personal representatives · regulator
  13. FDA Issues Class I Recalls of Datex-Ohmeda Infant Warmers Over Oxygen Delivery Defectapi.fda.gov · Jun 30, 2026 · regulator
  14. CPSC Recalls VEVOR Baby Loungers and AMASKY Nursing Pillows Over Infant Injury and Death Riskscpsc.gov · Jul 2, 2026 · regulator
  15. FDA Issues Class I Recall for Abiomed Impella CP Set Over Blood Clot Riskapi.fda.gov · Jul 6, 2026 · regulator
  16. RCOG: shoulder dystocia patient guidance
  17. AAOS: Erb’s palsy care guidance
  18. Bouchghoul et al.: shoulder dystocia prediction cohort

Checked against 18 primary sources by People's Justice editors · Updated

How we make money

People's Justice research team · Updated Oct 4, 2026