Injury guide

Paragard broke: care and records

A broken Paragard needs a clinician’s assessment. A retained piece and its location matter.

See If You Qualify

Free · No obligation · About 2 minutes

Updated Oct 4, 20269 sources

This may apply to you if

  • These suggestions help you prepare for a claim check. They are not a firm's acceptance rules.
  • Describe the device, removal and harm you want checked.
  • Prepare the procedure note and later care records if available.

What the public record says

These are cited sources. Their inclusion does not imply that they endorse People’s Justice or reviewed this page.

Jordan Sarver · Ohio University Heritage College of Osteopathic Medicine · First author of the cited case report

Finding: The report describes one retained fragment and a treatment decision based on several individual factors; it does not establish a population breakage rate.

Sarver: fractured copper IUD, original full case report (opens in a new tab) · Jan 23, 2021 · Checked Oct 3, 2026

The evidence and its limits

Ohio University Heritage College of Osteopathic Medicine, lead-author affiliation · Case Reports in Women's Health · 2021

Fractured copper IUD retained in the uterine wall leading to hysterectomy: a case report

Design:
Other study design
Participants:
One 38-year-old patient.
Finding:
A copper IUD broke during removal; a fragment remained in the uterine wall near the cervix. The patient later underwent surgery after consideration of several clinical factors.
Main limitation
Single case report without a comparison group or population denominator. It cannot establish a general breakage frequency, individual legal cause, or a universal need for hysterectomy. Full original report and declarations read; authors declared no funding or conflicts.

Read the source: Fractured copper IUD retained in the uterine wall leading to hysterectomy: a case report (opens in a new tab) · Checked Oct 3, 2026

The short answer

What is a broken IUD at removal?
Part of the device may break as it is taken out. The label tells clinicians to check that it is whole. A broken thread and a broken device are different findings. [5]
Which signs call for medical help?
Pain, heavy bleeding or fever need prompt advice. The label warns of serious infections and other problems. A missing thread alone does not show the cause. [5]
How is a retained piece diagnosed and treated?
A doctor checks the note and your condition. Images may help find a piece. The findings guide the care plan. [5]
What does the research say about a retained piece?
One report describes a retained piece and surgery. Other health factors shaped that patient’s care. The case does not set a care rule for everyone. [4]

What rules a case out

Not covered by this case

  • Having used Paragard alone does not decide a legal claim.
  • A symptom, public allegation or another patient’s treatment is not your diagnosis.

The process

What happens next

  1. 01

    You answer a few questions

    About two minutes. Nothing is sent until you agree on the last step and press submit.

  2. 02

    A lawyer looks at it

    A lawyer at the firm reads your answers and checks them against the current case criteria.

  3. 03

    The firm decides and gets in touch

    If the firm takes your case, you get the terms in writing to read before you sign. You can always say no.

When it fits this case

  • These suggestions help you prepare for a claim check. They are not a firm's acceptance rules.
  • Describe the device, removal and harm you want checked.
  • Prepare the procedure note and later care records if available.
  • Ask a lawyer to check the law and dates for your situation.

A broken Paragard needs a clinician’s assessment. A retained piece and its location matter. One published case cannot predict your treatment or prove your legal claim.

What is a broken IUD at removal?

Part of the device may break as it is taken out. The label tells clinicians to check that it is whole. A broken thread and a broken device are different findings.

The court’s complaint form asks about device breakage apart from thread or string breakage. Keep the removal note rather than assuming that missing strings mean a missing arm. The clinician should identify what was removed and what, if anything, remains.

Which signs call for medical help?

Pain, heavy bleeding or fever need prompt advice. The label warns of serious infections and other problems. A missing thread alone does not show the cause.

Severe pain or fever shortly after placement calls for immediate clinician contact. If you think you may be pregnant with Paragard in place, contact a clinician right away. Do not wait for a lawyer’s response or pull the threads to check for a fragment.

How is a retained piece diagnosed and treated?

A doctor checks the note and your condition. Images may help find a piece. The findings guide the care plan.

In the published case, inspection found one arm missing and ultrasound found the fragment in the uterine wall near the cervix. That is one patient’s finding, not a test order for everyone. Ask what your own images and report actually show.

What does the research say about a retained piece?

One report describes a retained piece and surgery. Other health factors shaped that patient’s care. The case does not set a care rule for everyone.

The patient also had bleeding, abnormal cervical findings and fibroids. The authors describe those factors when discussing surgery. The label says some difficult removals need surgery; it does not direct hysterectomy for every retained fragment.

Does breakage prove that I qualify for a claim?

Breakage alone does not prove a legal claim. The court lists claims about harm at removal. A lawyer needs your harm and time facts.

The short-form complaint separates the alleged breakage, injury, product identity and legal counts. A completed form is a statement of claims, not a ruling that the manufacturer caused your harm. Ask which missing fact matters to your particular review.

What records help after Paragard breaks?

Ask for the removal note and device findings. Request the image report if one was made. Note each attempted removal date.

Ask whether the office documented an intact device, a missing part or an embedded piece. Keep later procedure and follow-up reports with those records. Identify unavailable material as missing rather than supplying a date or conclusion from memory.

Find out where you stand.

The review is free and private. Asking for it doesn’t commit you to anything.

Register your interest

Sources

  1. ABA Model Rule 1.5: feesABA Model Rule 1.5: fees
  2. Southern District of New York: time limitsSouthern District of New York: time limits · court
  3. 45 CFR 164.524: access to health records45 CFR 164.524: access to health records · regulator
  4. Sarver: fractured copper IUD, original full case reportSarver: fractured copper IUD, original full case report · study
  5. DailyMed: Paragard prescribing informationDailyMed: Paragard prescribing information · regulator
  6. May: Paragard Doc868 time-limit orderMay: Paragard Doc868 time-limit order · court
  7. Northern District of Georgia: Paragard case summaryNorthern District of Georgia: Paragard case summary · court
  8. Teva reported that the first Paragard MDL test trial ended on February 3, 2026, with a verdict in its favor. This result concerns one case. As of October 6, 2026, ask your lawyer how it affects your claim and which later court orders apply.sahmcapital.com · Feb 3, 2026
  9. Northern District of Georgia: Paragard short-form complaint

Checked against 8 primary sources by People's Justice editors · Updated

How we make money

People's Justice research team · Updated Oct 4, 2026