People's Justice

Injury guide

Taking out mesh: questions for your care team

Mesh removal is a care decision based on your findings. Not every symptom needs the same treatment.

See If You Qualify

Free · No obligation · About 2 minutes

Updated Oct 4, 202614 sources

This may apply to you if

  • Prepare the mesh name, reason for repair and route used.
  • List symptoms, later care and the dates you know.
  • Bring any old claim or deal papers; ask a lawyer about your route.

What the public record says

These are cited sources. Their inclusion does not imply that they endorse People’s Justice or reviewed this page.

Fiona M. Reid · Warrell Unit, St Mary’s Hospital, Manchester University Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust · First-listed author of the original PROSPECT four- and six-year follow-up

Finding: At six years, the trial found no meaningful added symptom benefit from mesh inlays in primary vaginal prolapse repair. More women in the mesh arm had surgery for mesh problems, while greater pain or pain during sex was not detected across groups.

PROSPECT original four- and six-year randomized follow-up (opens in a new tab) · Aug 26, 2022 · Checked Oct 3, 2026

The evidence and its limits

Manchester University Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust and collaborating UK trial centers; NIHR funding · International Urogynecology Journal · 2022

PROSPECT four- and six-year follow-up: primary vaginal prolapse repair

Design:
Randomized controlled trial
Participants:
1,348 women in the primary-repair trial; 65% had six-year follow-up for the main symptom outcome
Finding:
No meaningful added symptom benefit from mesh inlays or biological graft. Mesh-arm removal surgery was 22/263 (8.4%); own-tissue comparator 4/255 (1.6%) in Table 2. Greater general pain or pain during sex was not detected across groups.
Main limitation
Questionnaire follow-up and attrition; no anatomical exam at 4/6 years; too small for rare harms. Primary-repair inlays are not every mesh kit or SUI sling. No personal cause or removal recommendation.

Read the source: PROSPECT four- and six-year follow-up: primary vaginal prolapse repair (opens in a new tab) · Checked Oct 3, 2026

The short answer

What is mesh removal meant to address?
A procedure may remove part or all of a mesh implant. The reason and extent depend on the problem. Mesh use alone does not require removal. [4]
Which symptoms should prompt a doctor visit?
Tell the care team about ongoing bleeding or unusual fluid. Report pelvic pain, groin pain or pain during sex. Do not wait for a claim review to discuss care. [2]
How is the removal plan diagnosed and treated?
Ask what the examination has confirmed. Discuss which treatment options fit that finding. Ask why partial or full removal is being considered. [4]
What does the research say about removal surgery?
Some women in the prolapse trial later had mesh removed. That count does not tell everyone to choose removal. The study did not test the best treatment for your symptoms. [6]

What rules a case out

Not covered by this case

  • A general finding does not decide the cause of your own harm.
  • These dated records do not decide a personal claim or care plan.

The process

What happens next

  1. 01

    You answer a few questions

    About two minutes. Nothing is sent until you agree on the last step and press submit.

  2. 02

    A lawyer looks at it

    A lawyer at the firm reads your answers and checks them against the current case criteria.

  3. 03

    The firm decides and gets in touch

    If the firm takes your case, you get the terms in writing to read before you sign. You can always say no.

When it fits this case

  • Prepare the mesh name, reason for repair and route used.
  • List symptoms, later care and the dates you know.
  • Bring any old claim or deal papers; ask a lawyer about your route.

Mesh removal is a care decision based on your findings. Not every symptom needs the same treatment. Ask what part of the mesh is involved and what a procedure could achieve.

What is mesh removal meant to address?

A procedure may remove part or all of a mesh implant. The reason and extent depend on the problem. Mesh use alone does not require removal.

FDA describes exposure through vaginal tissue as one complication that may need treatment. Some exposure can be managed without a major operation; other cases may need surgical removal. The public guidance does not promise that one approach will cure every symptom.

Which symptoms should prompt a doctor visit?

Tell the care team about ongoing bleeding or unusual fluid. Report pelvic pain, groin pain or pain during sex. Do not wait for a claim review to discuss care.

Bring the earlier repair history to the visit. If you are well and satisfied with surgery, FDA recommends routine follow-up without extra action. A market withdrawal and a personal clinical finding answer different questions.

How is the removal plan diagnosed and treated?

Ask what the examination has confirmed. Discuss which treatment options fit that finding. Ask why partial or full removal is being considered.

FDA’s sling guidance describes the mesh as a permanent implant and warns that later repairs can be more difficult. Ask the surgeon what outcome is realistic and what further complications are possible. A specialist’s second opinion may help when the original discussion leaves concerns unresolved.

What does the research say about removal surgery?

Some women in the prolapse trial later had mesh removed. That count does not tell everyone to choose removal. The study did not test the best treatment for your symptoms.

The trial’s six-year table reports removal in 22 of 263 mesh-arm participants. It compared initial prolapse repair methods, not random assignment to removal versus leaving mesh in place. Missing follow-up, no later physical examinations and rare-event limits prevent a personal removal prediction.

Does needing removal qualify me for compensation?

A procedure is a fact to review, not a promised payment. Keep its reason and findings clear. A lawyer must assess the claim and time rules.

The historical order treats individual cause evidence separately from general product issues. It does not say every removal is compensable or set a current award. Do not undergo an operation to strengthen a legal claim; decide care with the clinician.

What records should I keep from removal?

Keep the surgery note and follow-up plan. Ask what mesh was taken out or left in. Add the first implant record if you can.

Ask which product was involved and whether part of it remains. Record any later care recommendation as a recommendation, not an operation already performed. Ask about patient access and copying charges before assuming every requested record is free.

Find out where you stand.

The review is free and private. Asking for it doesn’t commit you to anything.

Register your interest

Sources

  1. FDA mesh activities: POP stop-sale and later reviewsFDA mesh activities: POP stop-sale and later reviews · regulator
  2. FDA patient information: pelvic organ prolapseFDA patient information: pelvic organ prolapse · regulator
  3. FDA patient information: stress urinary incontinenceFDA patient information: stress urinary incontinence · regulator
  4. FDA guidance: vaginal versus abdominal prolapse meshFDA guidance: vaginal versus abdominal prolapse mesh · regulator
  5. FDA review: mini-slings for stress urinary incontinenceFDA review: mini-slings for stress urinary incontinence · regulator
  6. PROSPECT original four- and six-year randomized follow-upPROSPECT original four- and six-year randomized follow-up · study
  7. Ethicon MDL2327 Pretrial Order337, entered May1,2019Ethicon MDL2327 Pretrial Order337, entered May1,2019 · court
  8. Southern District of West Virginia: Ethicon MDL2327 public archiveSouthern District of West Virginia: Ethicon MDL2327 public archive · court
  9. JPML cumulative terminated litigations through September30,2025JPML cumulative terminated litigations through September30,2025 · court
  10. New Jersey courts: Pelvic Mesh/Gynecare dated orders indexNew Jersey courts: Pelvic Mesh/Gynecare dated orders index · court
  11. ABA Model Rule1.5: feesABA Model Rule1.5: fees
  12. HHS individual access to health informationHHS individual access to health information · regulator
  13. SDNY: how long to file a complaintSDNY: how long to file a complaint · court
  14. US Courts: civil casesUS Courts: civil cases · court

Checked against 14 primary sources by People's Justice editors · Updated

How we make money

People's Justice research team · Updated Oct 4, 2026